Follow me on Substack HERE you'll get all new writing directly in your email inbox - for free!
Say “Bali” out loud. Then watch: the eye-roll, the smirk, the unsolicited travel opinion.
For a place this stunning, affordable, and spiritually decked-out, Bali cops an astonishing amount of flak. Some people rave about it. Others sneer. A few vow they’ll never go back. Others hope to stay forever, often with a smoothie bowl in hand.
Just this week, two Australians were shot in Bali and three others were arrested for the crime. The headlines came with the usual mix of horror, exoticism, and low-key judgment. This isn't the first time Bali has been in the news cycle, and it won’t be the last.
So what’s really going on?
I’m not about to settle the debate; instead I want to explore why the debate exists at all — what it reveals about us, our tastes, and our need to sort the world into “cool” and “cringe,” even when it comes to our holiday choices.
Bali: Too Basic or Too Much?
Maybe Bali’s crime is being too accessible. Too many bogans in Bintang singlets. Too many yoga mums on juice cleanses. Too many sunburnt Aussies learning to haggle for the first time, then Instagramming it like a rite of passage.
It’s the destination where you first ride a scooter, dodge spiritual burnout, and experience a different culture (and maybe some gastro). It’s thrilling, chaotic, and stunning — and yes, at times, it can be a bit much.
But when something becomes so familiar — when even your dentist has a villa in Bali — it stops feeling like a discovery. And for our collective imagination, that’s dangerous.
Bali in the News: Scooters, Scandals, and Spiritual Selfies
The media eats Bali stories like Nasi Goreng at 2am. Arrests, monkeys, influencers in Ubud claiming enlightenment — all framed with the same half-patronising smirk.
It creates a shorthand: “Bali = chaos.” Or “Bali = Instagram fakery.” The more often this message gets repeated, the more it sticks, regardless of how narrow it is.
To balance the books, I ran a quick poll. Asked people what they love and hate about Bali. The results? Warm. Messy. Contradictory. Just like the island itself.
Temples. Traffic. Kindness. Chaos. Spirituality. Scooters. Gastro. Grace.
These aren’t just opinions. They’re micro-memoirs. Snapshots of longing, joy, irritation, love. A thousand Bali stories, stitched together from memory and meaning.
Travel as Performance
Let’s be honest: our travel choices are never just about rest and relaxation. They serve as social signals.
Patagonia = rugged. Amalfi = tasteful. Bali? Well, it depends.
If you say you’re heading to Ubud, people nod. Canggu? They judge. Kuta? They contact the embassy.
Even in Bali, there’s a hierarchy of acceptability—a caste system of cool.
Why? Because we’re not just travelling anymore — we’re consuming identity. We want our travel to mean something. Transformation. Perspective. A better Tinder profile. And we judge other people’s choices as if they threaten our own.
Bali Is a Mirror
There are legitimate criticisms of Bali as a tourism machine, such as overdevelopment, pollution, Western entitlement, spiritual bypassing, and cultural commodification.
But when we laugh at Bali, are we really laughing at the island — or at the version of ourselves we pretend not to be?
Bali is both a paradise and a problem. It’s peace and pollution. It’s barefoot ceremonies at dawn and traffic jams at dusk. It’s complicated.
Like us.
So What Is Bali, Really?
Maybe Bali isn’t a destination. Maybe it’s a mirror.
It shows you who you are — or who you think you’re meant to be. And sometimes that’s enlightening. Other times, a bit uncomfortable.
So sure, roll your eyes at Bali. But don’t pretend it’s just about Bali.
That flinch? That opinion? That smug superiority or secret longing?
Bali isn’t the one performing. We are.
PS You can follow me on Substack HERE to get any new writing directly in your email inbox!